New York Pizza in Amstel III/Bullewijk

What a fantastic place! The manager is great, engaging, and knows what he's talking about. Super delicious pizza. The freshest and best quality in Amsterdam. I love coming here after a concert!

The pizzas were stale, oily, and tasted like they had been sitting out for hours. The staff were shockingly rude and dismissive — they made me feel like I was begging for food instead of being a paying customer. Easily one of the worst dining experiences I’ve ever had.

I was recently queuing overnight with my friends for a concert at AFAS Live. The staff at New York Pizza brought us 4 pizzas that were leftover at the end of their night before they closed! Very kind and considerate of them. And the pizza was soooo good!

employees are very friendly and look representative

We camed 10.40 and its close..timing said open till 11pm...

Reheated and tough pizza. Bland and greasy. Fortunately, they didn't let me order a full pizza.

I went there after Jin's concert at the nearby dome along with many fans. The staff stayed open later to serve everyone and then even stayed there late playing music for us! They were really kind. The pizza is also delicious. A perfect pizza place.

Best pizza in town and Coolest staff 10/10

We had the best time partying there after the concert thanks to the guy that played our requested music for us ~ hopefully get to come back again after more concerts.

I visited before a big concert. The line was accordingly long. Nevertheless, the staff were polite and the service was very quick. I thought the pizza was good.

Greasy pizza and a grumpy, rude cashier — the perfect combo to ruin your appetite!

I walked in at a quarter to nine to get a pistachio bread. I was helped by a young lady. In response to my order she said: we only have slices. I didn't really understand what she meant by this. So I indicated again that I would like the pistachio Bread. Without any emotion or customer friendliness she gave the following answer: we only have slices. Then I indicated that I didn't quite understand what she meant. Only then did she explain that they were no longer making new things and that they therefore only had slices. Then it seemed to me as if she meant that they only had pieces of that bread. Apparently they didn't. 0 clarity and 0 customer friendliness.

Had a great meal here and my friends love coming too!

I’m ordered pizza via Uber eats. But I didn’t get my orders. Is crazy

The floor was dirty while it was only myself, my girlfriend and 2 other people inside. The staff were more interested in using their phones than making sure the dining area was clean and presentable. one female member of staff did not look up from her phone while we were there. The male member of staff was controlling the music which was not family friendly. Service while receiving food was not good. Food was only placed on the table with no words. It felt as though we were Inconveniencing the staff to be eating here. Overall the staff were not willing to interact with customers and would rather be on their phones. Cleanliness is sub par. Would not recommend this location or eat here again.

This place was everything I needed after a long day and a concert! I got the 2 slice and drink deal (pepperoni and Mexican hot with sauce on both) tasted 10/10, staff were friendly and there’s seats to sit outside.

Great that you are participating in tgtg. This way, as a single mother, I can make my son happy for an affordable price, with tasty pizza slices 🍕. I come back here more often with my mother and son.

Flies 🪰 around pizza having fun. Staff least bothered about the hygiene. It seems the fly was having a pizza party. I did capture one and have posted. Please take notice and improve food hygiene standard.

We been waiting for 2 hours now and still my order not delivered and when we call them they hang up on us and after a lot of calls they say we sorry we don’t have gluten free pizza anymore after 2 damn hours f them

The dough is very good, both the thin and normal ones.

It's been unmanned for 20 minutes. Employees just leave the store. Never experienced anything like this before. So many customers have walked out and some are waiting.

I had bad costumer experience which left me disappointed with this place, from which I have tried to buy pizza TWICE, and was let down Twice. First time I went there was on a Wednesday night, around 10:15pm and they were already closed even though it says both online and on their front page that they close at 11pm. Second time going there to buy a whole pizza and staff rudely told me they had no more pizza dough left at 9:30pm while trying to sell me the old pizza slices on display. So I went to the other New York pizza store that is less than 350 meters away to receive a very welcoming service and delicious pizza. Not coming back at all at this place.

The pizza base was really crispy and the Margherita slice pizza itself was super tasty. No long waiting time because the pizzas are ready and just have to be pushed through an oven. Unfortunately we couldn't get a whole pizza or sit inside because the chairs were already up. I think €3.49 for a pizza slice is a little too expensive but all in all it was great :)

Nice staff and the garlic bread is really delicious

I Ordered bbq meat lover, tasted different from the one I get from the other store branch and tasted bad . Never going back there 😠 trash

Ok, the pizza is quite tasty, but it is ready-made in the display case, so they can't do much wrong with that. There are two young men and a girl behind the counter who do not look at us when ordering and when new customers arrive they are clearly more interested in their mobile phones. When we leave the shop they don't say anything and don't even look up. It may not be a place where we expect 3 stars, but at least have some decency. Really, really bad advertisement for New York Pizza this couple.

The pizzas were okay, but the staff and helpfulness are poor and even brutal.

Burned potatoe wedges without the sauce we ordered.

Claims 60 second pizza!!! but it's not really!! by the time you get your order taken then receive that hot slice it's more like 120 seconds but that is fantastic and the quality is better than some of that nasty Italian nonsense. garlic bread is perfect to chase the pizza down 👌🍁🍁🍁🍁🍁highly recommend (if your serious just ask them to bake you a whole pizza)

Not the best place. The attention wasn't even "kind", seemed like you weren't even welcome there. They weren't too open to speak english either.

It's for take-out and I saw lots of delivery people in front of the pizzaria. They are young and motivated

مطعم وجبات سريعة متخصص بالبيتزا لا بأس به. قريب من ملعب يوهان كرويف الشهير. ايضا يقع في منطقة حيويه وجيدة وبالقرب منه عده محلات شهيرة. طلبت بيتزا مارغريتا من المطعم ولكن للامانة لم تكن لذيذه جدا، الكثير من الصلصة والعجينة قاسية.

Sehr leckere Pizza für einen guten Preis!

Ze praten liever met vrienden aan de bar dan dat ze het personeel bedienen, je vraagt 2 slices en ze vergeten het dan nog ook. Zeer onvriendelijk.

Good vibe. Nice Pizza. Vegetarian slices are good as well.

Leckere Pizza mit typisch dicken und fluffigen amerikanischen Boden.

Popped in here for a quick couple of slices. Staff were nice and the pizza was quick. Definitely a good pit stop.

Pizza boa e gostosa. Atendimento top

Fantastische pizza winkel Stef heeft ons fantastisch geholpen

Snelle service & prima personeel. Eten erg zout en niet extreem smaakvol, en de wachtrij is erg onduidelijk. Duur ook wel een beetje. Krijgt een bordje in plaats van doosje, ik neem aan dat je de pizza voor takeaway maar in je jaszak moet proppen?

Auch wenn sie „nur“ warm gemacht wurde, hat uns die Pizza geschmeckt. Insbesondere die Peperoni Salami Pizza war gut - thanks

The pepperoni pizza 🍕 was delicious, one slice is filling enough.

Friendly service but the pizza isn’t great. It is bland and not fresh - running it through the oven again was not sufficient to make it taste fresh.

Best sweet chili chicken pizza ever!

I have been to New york pizza before and they are not bad, if you want to order takeaway from this however, do not do it through Ubereats as I did. They have a problem with taking orders from Ubereats because of the format of post code of my address, I waited for 2 hours, called directly at the restaurant a few times, all I got were standard robitic answers telling me that the order would come soon, but eventually found out that the order was not actually made. I believe it was mostly a problem with Ubereats, but both parties just ignore the problem.

Vriendelijk personeel en heerlijke pizza’s 👌🏼

Als je 3 weken de baas bent en het zo goed voor elkaar hebt ben je gewoon net zo goed als jullie pizza pepperoni :) Thanks guys. See you soon

Lekkere pizza vriendelijke bediening en snel!