New York Pizza in IJburg Zuid

Pizzas used to be well-topped. For the past few years, it's been a SEARCH for the toppings and a SEARCH for the flavor. The toppings are minimal. What you mostly buy is a dry, oven-baked piece of dough with a tiny sprinkle of topping 🔍 Frozen pizzas for a few euros from the supermarket or for a few euros more from the refrigerated section are much tastier (more toppings, more flavor). I wonder when New York Pizza will go bankrupt. Nobody eats this these days, do they?

After three years it is still not possible to have it delivered to the herring tube dike (lock house)

Hi. In April 2025, I placed one order here. I don't often order from NY Pizza, but I generally like their products very much. My order consisted of a 4 cheese, 40 cm NY Style Pizza, and x20 crispy chicken wings, for takeout. The ready time was quick, like under 15 minutes, maybe even under 10 minutes, and it matched very well with the time window they shared via the website. Visually, all looked good. See the pics of the boxes and how the food looked in them. Taste, however, was a disappointment for me. The pizza seemed to have all ingredients, but was bland. No taste; I don't know how that happens. Also, the garlic sauce that I ordered on the borders (is standard) seemed to have no effect, as if it was absent. I don't know why I ate this pizza. The crispy chicken wings had a delicious taste of the crust, like, that is the target taste. However, it wasn't well stuck to the meat. It was, in part, piling off on its own as the wings moved, and it was too easy to separate them. The meat was on the verge of what I could eat. I am not an expert, and I want to believe they prepped the meat well, but it was again so bland (also as chicken), and maybe the word is watery that, again, I wondered why I would eat it. It was edible, but not something enjoyable. My stomach wasn't happy with it, but I had no problems after eating these products. Altogether, I can't give this experience more than a 2/5.

Your standard quick pizza delivery and take away. The people are nicer than the food.

I had to wait 1.5 hours for my pizza, and when it finally came, I got an ice cold pizza. If you want a nice hot pizza that is delivered on time. You should definitely not order here. And there was no taste to it.

The pizza that was delivered seemed like it had been sitting out for days. Gross! Staff were rude about the wait time for delivery just down the road. Not worth it, I should have paid attention to the other reviews.

Worst pizza I've ever had in Amsterdam. The delivery took far too long and the pizza arrived cold and hard. Really, we shouldn't have to pay for something inedible that ends up in the trash. DON'T GET PIZZA HERE.

Great pizza. I accidentally checked pick up somewhere (without knowing) while I wanted to have it delivered. I called and within 15 minutes someone was at the door with my pizza. Top!!

Order here often and always tasty and warm

Your delivery person hit me with their motorcycle while swerving on the SIDEWALK. Thankfully I am alright but he could've hit a child. He did not even stopped to apologize. I don't care how fast you have to deliver but do not ride on the sidewalk and hit people!

Taking long and pizza arrives cold. In this time you can just go to the supermarket and buy a frozen one. In both scenarios you have to heat it in the oven so that you can eat it.

I first had to wait almost 2 hours for a pizza, buffalo wings and drinks. Then they forgot the drinks and never came back. This is not the first time, but it will certainly be the last for me.

NYP is not very tasty. The garlic cheesy contains a lot of pieces of frozen garlic. Furthermore, most pizzas (e.g. pulled chicken) have little taste. The BBQ pizza way too much sauce. The pizza deliverers are not always friendly, especially that light-skinned boy with a black ponytail. Plus the lady who usually answers the phone comes across as very unfriendly and grumpy.

Pizza delivered against my dietary requests so we couldn't even eat it.

Good service. They forgot the topping on 1 of the 2 pizzas, I got 2 completely new extra pizzas. Top

I fear they are going back to old practices when they were owned by the previous owners

Some items are Halal, you can ask before order if you looking for Halal.

Heel vriendelijk mensen lekker pizza altijd vers echt super niks te klagen

Lekkere pizza’s snelle bezorging

Snelle service. Foutje werd meteen rechtgezet.

Heerlijke pizza en personeel erg vriendelijk

Heerlijke pizza! Er is veel veranderd sinds de zaak is overgenomen. Gelukkig maar ik bestel hier nu veel vaker. Bedankt toppers!

Very good experience today. Chef also makes a nice vegan pizza.

Heerlijke pizzas, stuk beter dan dominos, sws ff proberen. Meestal gewoon lekker snel en anders is het het wachten wel waard. Caprese is echt een aanrader!

Eerste bestelling en helaas na 1 uur en 50 nog steeds geen pizza. Maar 1 bezorger op IJburg. Jammer en voor mij een reden om deze lage review te geven en geen pizza meer te bestellen.

Lekkere pizza gegeten, vriendelijk personeel.

They make very good pizzas. I don't know that why people rate them bad. They put enough toppings on the pizza. Only bad thing about their pizza is that it is very oily and unhealthy. Every time i eat from New York pizza i get chest burns because of the spicy toppings they put in the pizza. Try hot vegetable pizza. Its Tasty! Highly recommended

Fantastische pizza tent. De pizzas waren vorige keer een paar uur te laat door drukte en ze hebben het goed gemaakt door onze volgende bestelling gratis te maken. Amazing. Ook heerlijke pizzas. Top!!!!!!!

De pizza's zijn lekker. Ze hebben een goeie voedselkwaliteit.

Best staff and tasty food fast delivery also

KL begon uit het niks te freestylen voor me deur.

Heerlijke pizza. Ik ben fan geworden!

goede pizzas, snel klaar en aardig personeel!

Ik ben geen pizza liefhebber en dit was het enige wat in de buurt open was, maar ik kan je vertellen na deze service en heerlijke pizza heb ik me lievelings tent gevonden. Heel vriendelijk en grappig personeel en de pizza’s waren van top kwaliteit geen 1 minpunt kunnen vinden!

Heerlijke pizza en nog snel geleverd ook !!

het eten was heerlijk! ze waren klantvriendelijk en de pizza was erg lekker. Ik raad het zeker aan om hier te eten! :)

Ik van de week pizza besteld en de bezorging was top en de pizza ook. Ga zeker vaker bestellen!

Snelle service en heerlijke pizza's. Voor herhaling vatbaar 👌🏿

Hartstikke goede en lekkere pizza´s. Ik haal gemiddeld 2x in de week een pizza en niet te vergeten de overheerlijke pizza rol. Jullie doen het goed ga zo door!

Heerlijke Pizza gegeten! Hij was snel klaar & super klantvriendelijk personeel. Zeker een aanrader 👍🏽

Super snelle levering en goed eten. Ben erg tevreden over de kwaliteit van het eten de service! Zeker een aanrader!

Pizza is mijn lievelings eten. En bij deze NY Pizza zaak komt ie zeker in de top 5. De zaak is schoon en het personeel vriendelijk. De pizza was heerlijk. Ik heb er meteen 2 genomen. Een echte aanrader. Mooi ook dat ik om de hoek woon 🤤🤤

Uitzonderlijke service, en hoger standaard van kwaliteit als bij je reguliere NYP filialen! Definitely the place to be if you've got the munchies💪🏽

Sinds de opening eten wij wekelijks bij deze new york pizza, heerlijk eten en aardige personeel

Heerlijke pizza en top service! Zeker een aanrader!

Top service, besteld en snel mijn pizza gekregen.

Heerlijke pizzas!! Heb vaker hier besteld en ik ben altijd tevreden. Zeker een aanrader!

Lekker pizza, Snel geleverd, top zaak!

Pizza was snel klaar en zeer smakelijk!! De pizza rolls zijn niet te missen. In 1 woord geweldig!! Zeer vriendelijk personeel en goed advies voor een lekkere pizza!!