New York Pizza in Oostelijk Havengebied

From the moment we walked in, the customer service was poor — we felt unwelcome and were met with rudeness. The staff left us midway through placing our order, which added to the frustration. There also appeared to be no dress code, as one of the servers was wearing sliders and jeans half way down his arse — not the most professional look. We were told there would be a one-hour wait for the food, which we accepted, and returned after an hour to collect it. Unfortunately, the pizza was cold, rubbery, and SO dry! and simply not enjoyable. A real letdown, especially considering how promising the place looks from the outside. We had high hopes, but sadly it didn’t deliver.

17/05/2025 at 11:27 i am there The service is really bad, the people are rude, you are not allowed to drink or To breath Or To go toilette You are not allowed to do anything I understand it is take-away, but even if you buy a drink there , you ca not drink it it has to be closed or empty, even if you open it and you are not drinking it, it is not allowed. ---- The environment is very toxic, the staff working there, were loud, it feels like fighting ------ In conclusion they are not friendly at all, and the are not supposed to be communicating with customers

We ordered pizza delivery, the courier didn't even try to call or go inside and leave it at the reception, terrible service

I've honestly never had cold pizza from them. Always fresh, piping hot and absolutely great. Good delivery people too.

picked up the pizzas and they were very tasty. The dough is very good and the vegan toppings were also convincing.

I made an order through the app and it showed that it was being prepared. After 50 minutes I called them to check why was it taking so long and for my surprise they had already closed. I keep wondering how can they accept an order if they are about to close. On the app it was still showing that it was being prepared, so if I hadn't called I would be waiting for another hour. Next day I contacted the app to get a refund and was surprised to see that the order was shown as delivered. How dishonest is that?

CRAP. we waited for the order which never arrived. We walked to get the order and were told the guy called and we didn't answer but I showed the guy proof that no call ever came. The order was inedible charred and incomplete because he had not even given the water that we had already paid for. Grumpy staff and incapable of fixing the unpleasant situation they created. Never again in life.

What a sweet boy. Hi just makes a pizza that is out of the range and also adds something tasty. Keep it up great 💪🏻

Best pizza good service delivered quickly

I had a nice experience with employee Mello at Pizza Newyork. Super friendly and made sure my order was ready on time. Service like that makes me want to come back :-) and pizza tasted great. Thank you

Worst New York pizza around. I sometimes order from here because this branch is the closest (10 min) but the food has often arrived cold and always has a long delivery time.

cold food, waited more than 90 minutes, wrong information on the phone, they were supposed to send a credit by app which of course did not happen, pizza 4 types of cheese without tomato sauce which ultimately makes it just a melted fake cheese sandwich, terrible service. What a mistake to order something here.

Pizza was fresh and great! Wished the family deal would have been as big as the individual slices.

I recently had the chance to try a delicious pizza and I must say I was very impressed. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, just as it should be. The sauce was rich and full of flavor, with just enough spices to give a subtle kick without being overpowering. However, what really made this pizza special were the fresh ingredients: juicy tomatoes, creamy mozzarella and fresh basil, all in perfect harmony. It was clear that care had been taken with the quality of every element. I would definitely recommend this pizza to any pizza lover. I'll definitely be back for more!

Terrible customer service and dry and mediocre pizza. We accidentally ordered a pizza for pickup instead of delivery and called less than a minute later to cancel, only to be told it wasn’t possible—even though the order hadn’t been processed yet. When we arrived to pick it up, a heavy rainstorm started, and both we and a family with a small child were forced to leave the shop because they claimed they didn’t have a license for people to stay inside. It wasn’t even closing time—it was only 7pm. I can understand if they couldn’t cancel the order, but showing no empathy by kicking people out into a storm? They acted like robots, completely lacking basic human decency. I decided to try New York Pizza once to check it out, will never try again.

Horrible staff who have always looked angry and hostile. The pizza didn't taste that bad to be fair but after eating one of their signature pastries, I was very poorly all day the next day and haven't actually recovered fully after 10 days of being home. I personally will 'NEVER' buy food from this place again.

Delicious pizzas fast delivery 🍕🍕🍕

nyp has very good service, the employees do their work very well and quickly, there are also very good ones, such as 2nd pizza for free...

Delicious pizza! Nice meal. Customer friendly!

Very customer friendly and delicious hot pizzas!!

Pizzas always arrive nice and hot.

We ordered 2 small pepperoni pizza’s… must be the easiest thing ever right? Well guess not we got dough with some red paste I think it must represent some kind of tomato spread but there wasn’t even cheese or pepperoni on the pizza… what the hell is this.

The worlds driest pizza For 26€ you basically get 2 pieces of dough - sauce and ingredients were put on top so scarcely, it doesn’t even matter what you order, all you taste is dry dough anyways. Extremely disappointing and not worth the money. Will not order again. The pizza did arrive very fast though, to at least mention 1 positive aspect. Not even 30min.

Food never even came what a joke

Food was pretty guud but there was unfriendly and unprofessional personell, which was not hygenic.

The food and delivery were excellent

I ordered pizza and picked it up myself, the pizza baker was nice and pizza was good, but the cashier is very arrogant and unfriendly, I think he needs such a social skills course to be able to deal with customers

two small pizzas, tasty ('clean on'), and would certainly have been rated better if it were €18, but certainly not for €24! staff was great!

Pizzas never delivered. After a long wait, I called the restaurant, after which a very unfriendly person who had never heard of customer service indicated that the doorbell had been rung and not opened. Of course, the doorbell was never rung and why would a customer who is hungry and waiting for pizzas not open the door. They did not want to return the money or redeliver it. The person couldn't tell me what happened to the pizzas either. Judging by all the other reactions, this is unfortunately more the rule than the exception. Easy money to make...Will never order anything from there again!

Pizza never arrived. The app said it was delivered at 23:00. Exactly the moment they were not reachable anymore. I demand my money back ASAP. Do not order here, it’s a scam.

Delivers to wrong address manager insults customer!

Unfortunately the same experience as many others. We waited almost 3 hours in total and called 3 times in the meantime, with the standard answer always being 'your pizza can be here any moment'. Huge recommendation.

Worst pizzas I have ever had in my life. NEVER ordering from this place again! They need to shut this place down- it’s a disaster!

What great results! These guys and gals know their stuff. Wanted fast a pizza, they called to confirm it and there it was! Heerlie

Waiting 2 hours for a cold pizza in a half open box

Almost two months ago I ordered a pizza + chicken nuggets online from New York Pizza and paid via iDeal. The pizza arrived too late and was a completely different pizza than I ordered: smaller and of a different taste. The nuggets didn't come. I returned the pizza to the courier. Immediately called New York Pizza, but they were no longer available by phone. Since then I have had many emails with customer service, but they do not come up with a solution and will not refund my money. A registered letter with this complaint has so far remained unanswered. The customer is not respected. Mistakes are not corrected. Complaints are ignored. Other people's money will not be returned. You should be ashamed of yourselves.

What a miserable thing. We call you to say that a pizza is out of stock and which one we want differently. Ask for a pepperoni pizza and after 1 hour we receive an improvised pizza that we had not ordered. Call and apologies, apologies the pepperoni is coming. Now 2 hours later nothing has arrived and they are no longer answering the phone! Scandalous!!!!

Cold pizzas after 2 hours of waiting.

Ice melted and refrozen, making the entire bottom water ice, yuck! Moreover, we ordered non-dairy and received 2 different ice creams with a milk base. Sloppy!

NY Pizza Jollemanhof A'dam. Al meerdere malen hele (veel te) late bezorging en koude pizza's gekregen alsmede besteld product 'vergeten'. Na vele malen bellen div. (slechte) excuses waarom de levering zo lang duurt. Wat is dat toch met deze locatie van NY Pizza?! Ik wacht ook nog steeds op een antwoord van NY Pizza na mijn klacht. Bizar, slechte service.

Snel bezorgd, heerlijk eten. Vaak goede kortingsacties! Makkelijk te bestellen en na maar een half uurtje heerlijk warm eten gekregen. Voor herhaling vatbaar! 😍❤️‍🔥👏

I didn’t have a high expectations tbh but when I was there the staff were nice they were very helpful and the pizza’s were amazing like really good. So definitely recommended!!

Heerlijk bizza en goeie service 👌🏼

tasty pizza and delivered on time

Surprisingly- really tasteful pizza. I took vegetarian and it was so good. Service was also nice and price was reasonable.

Fantastic taste Highly recommended

Leider auch bei schlimmsten Wetter nur "to Go". Pizza war Recht hart und trocken, die Tomatensauce ist sehr dominant. Müsste nicht nochmal sein.

Nur zum mitnehmen!!! Die Pizza ist sehr ölig/fettig Leider ist die Pizza nicht ganz durchgeschnitten worden dadurch nicht einfach auf der Straße zu essen. Ich würde sie nicht noch einmal kaufen. Schade

The person behind the counter was rude to everyone: to me, other clients and her colleagues.

جميله جدا طلبت منها بيتزا مارجرتا وشاورما وخضار مره حلوه وسوفليه لذيذ لازانيا مره جميله 👍👍👍👍

Goede intenties om een heerlijke pizza te bereiden waren zeker aanwezig

Verkeerde pizza meegegeven en miste ons lava cakeje. Die opgehaald. Pizza was wel ontzettend heet en smaakte gelukkig erg lekker maar natuurlijk niet waar je voor betaald. Personeel was vriendelijk maar de zaak is niet erg hygiënisch. Alles is een beetje vies, oud en smoezelig

I needed a pizza place to get some dinner near my hotel, and New York Pizza delivered. When I went in they were helpful and friendly, the pizza was prepared and cooked quickly, and most importantly the pizza was delicious. I will definitely order from them again next time I'm in Amsterdam.

Zoals ze vandaag hebben bezorgd, zou voor mij altijd een reden zijn om opnieuw te bestellen. Pizza's lekker warm, alsof ze net van de oven uit gekomen zijn. Prima op tijd ondanks de drukte en pizza's exact naar mijn wens zonder fouten.

Heel lekker pizza en goeie service ook hele goeie koeriers

Goede pizza, werd heel snel bezorgd…

Lekkere pizza! De vegan truffel pizza is een echte aanrader! Ook de east side showarma pizza beviel mijn man goed. Vriendelijke staf en snelle pizza. We hadden new York style maar gelukkig was de bodem wel knapperig!

Heerlijke pizza, heb er echt van genoten. Ik kom snel weer langs. Thanks voor de zoetigheid erbij. Waren er maar meer ondernemers zoals jullie. Tot snel

nette, Heerlijke, pizza, heb er echt van genoten! goeie bakkers en klantvriendelijke medewerkers! ga zo door Ik kom snel weer langs !